Weeknight Banana Bread

This tender, moist banana bread couldn’t be easier to make – perfect for a weeknight. It starts with melted butter so everything can be mixed together by hand. No mixer required. Sour cream (or yogurt) gives the bread its soft texture.

Few types of recipes are passed around as much as banana bread recipes. My theory is that it’s because every time you taste a new version you’re reminded of just how delicious a genre this is. It’s sweet enough to taste like a treat but somehow we give ourselves permission to eat it any time of day (fruit!). With the weather cooling, it feels like baking season has truly arrived. And, if we learned anything from March 2020, it’s that baking is good therapy. And warm banana bread is inexpensive and effective therapy indeed.

This version of banana bread is entirely my own, but borrows a bit from all the favorites I’ve gathered from family and friends. Sour cream for tang and moisture, a mix of white and brown sugar for a golden color inside and dark crust outside, a pinch of cinnamon to highlight the banana flavors.

I tested nearly 15 versions of this bread in search of the right balance, because at the end of the day, I wanted this to be a recipe that feels easy. Just a reliably delicious quick bread that is no fuss, mixes up in a few minutes, and turns an overripe piece of produce into a bounty of warm, soft, banana goodness. I wanted this to be the recipe you mix up on a Tuesday while dinner is in the oven. It’s weeknight-friendly (but great for a cozy weekend afternoon too). 

What you’ll see throughout this post is the same recipe with both chocolate chips and without. I couldn’t pick a favorite. Sometimes I love a plain warm slice of banana bread with a spread of butter. But sometimes you need the chocolate.

Ingredients

• Unsalted Butter – This recipe uses melted butter for simplicity. Let it cool slightly before mixing into the batter. If you only have salted butter, no worries – just omit the added salt in the recipe.
• Mashed Banana – See below for my tips on ripeness of bananas for bread.
• White and Brown Sugar – A mix of two types of sugars give the bread golden color inside and a defined crust on the outside.
• Sour Cream – A bit of dairy helps to retain moisture in the bread. Plain or Greek yogurt will work just fine too.
• Eggs, All-Purpose Flour, Vanilla, Baking Soda, Salt, and Ground Cinnamon – Just your standard line-up of baking ingredients. The cinnamon is barely noticeable in the finished bread, but it really helps to make the banana flavor shine.

Melted vs. Softened Butter in Banana Bread

The texture and temperature of butter has a huge effect on the finished product of nearly all baking recipes that use it. Most cookie recipes require butter that is soft enough to blend but not melted. Softened butter can hold air and be whipped with sugar into that fluffy consistency that gives cookies a crumbly texture. With banana bread, that crumbly texture is less important since what most of us are looking for in banana bread is that it’s moist and tender. Using melted butter gives this banana bread a less crumbly texture than using softened butter and a slightly more spongy texture.

When I first pictured this recipe, I wanted to be sure that it worked with melted butter – hence the “weeknight-friendly” title. I did not want to wait for butter to soften and wanted everything to mix together easily, without the need to “cream” the butter and sugar together with a mixer.

(Note: once I got this recipe just right, I went back and tested it with softened butter. The result? It’s great either way. If you’re in a rush, just melt that butter. If you have some extra time, feel free to wait until the butter softens.)

How Ripe Should the Bananas Be?

When ripe bananas are speckled with brown spots, they are ready for banana bread. Yellow bananas with brown spots on most of the surface will make a banana bread with a light crumb that holds its shape well. Very ripe bananas that are brown all over will lend more sweetness to the bread and will make a bread that is more dense and soft.

I often mash a bunch of bananas and freeze them in jars, so they’re ready to be made into banana bread any time. Frozen and defrosted bananas behave a lot like very ripe bananas and the resulting bread is usually more dense than when using fresh bananas.

How to Freeze Mashed Bananas

Mash ripe bananas with a fork until nearly smooth. Transfer the mashed bananas into Mason jars, leaving about 1 inch of headspace at the top. Seal with a lid and freeze for up to 6 months.

I love to buy a bunch of extra bananas to let ripen and then freeze so that I can make banana bread any time. To mash a large portion of bananas, use the paddle attachment on a standing mixer and mix just until all of the large pieces are mashed.

Best Mix-Ins for Banana Bread

Add any of these great mix-ins to your banana bread (use ¾ to 1 cup of mix-ins per loaf):

• Chocolate Chips (regular or mini)
• Chopped Dark Chocolate
• Chopped Pecans / Walnuts
• Dried Fruit (dried cranberries or raisins)
• Peanut Butter Chips or Peanut Butter Powder
• Nut Butter or Nutella (swirl these into the top of the bread before baking)

Other Banana Recipes

• Banana Bread Crumb Cake
• Banana Bread Bundt Cake with Chocolate
• Baked Banana French Toast with Pecan Crumble
• Banana Bread Bars with Brown Butter Cinnamon Icing
• Strawberry Banana Muffins
• Banana Bread Cupcakes

Favorite Tools

• Anchor 3-Piece Glass Mixing Bowls
• Pyrex Loaf Pan
• Whisk 

If you want to geek out on a whole variety of banana bread recipes, check out The Pancake Princess’ Best Banana Bread Bake-Off. She did all the work to identify a recipe that will fit any type of banana bread your heart desires!

Here’s a very focussed June helping to test banana bread recipes!

*This post contains affiliate links*